Roof know-how for Coalville homes
Mortar or dry fix: how should a ridge and verge be finished?
If a roofer has looked at your ridge or your gable ends lately, he has probably offered you a choice. Put it back in sand and cement as it was, or change to a dry system with clips and screws.
One may cost less today. The other may last longer. Here is what you are choosing between.
The old way: sand and cement
For most of the last century, the top and edges of a tiled roof were finished with mortar. Ridge tiles were pressed into a bed of it along the top. At the gable ends, the gap under the last tile was filled with it and smoothed off.
It worked, and on thousands of roofs it is still working. Its weakness is that mortar is stiff and a roof is not. Timber swells and shrinks, tiles heat up and cool down, wind rocks the whole structure a hair's breadth. After enough years the bond cracks.
Mortar also depends on the day it was laid. Too wet, too dry, too cold or mixed too weak, and it fails early. You cannot tell from the ground which sort you have got until bits arrive on the path.
The new way: dry fix
A dry ridge has no mortar at all. A timber batten is fixed along the top of the roof. A ventilated roll is laid over it and stuck down on to the tiles either side. Each ridge tile is then screwed through into the batten, with a plastic clip sealing the joint to the next one.
A dry verge works on the same idea. Interlocking plastic caps are fixed over the ends of the tiles and battens, one for each row, from the gutter to the top.
The result can move with the roof without cracking. The ridge roll also lets a little air out of the top of the loft, which helps with condensation.
What the rule book says
The British Standard for slating and tiling is BS 5534. The Roof Tile Association's guide to roof tile fasteners says all ridge, hip and verge tiles must be mechanically fixed, even when they are bedded in mortar.
That standard is written for new work. It does not make your old mortared ridge illegal, and nobody will ask you to change it. It does tell you which way the trade has gone, and why a careful roofer re-bedding a ridge today should add a fixing to each tile.
Typical costs for each, from published guides
Published UK cost guides print ridge figures by job size, and they do not split a full ridge replacement into mortar and dry versions. Ask your roofer to price both on your own roof.
| Job | UK guide price |
|---|---|
| Re-pointing ridge tiles, per 10 metres | £200 to £300 |
| Whole ridge replaced on a semi (8 to 10 metres) | £500 to £700typical about £600 |
| Dry verge system on a standard semi | £500 to £1,500typical about £1,000 |
These are typical UK prices from published UK cost guides, and a roofer must see your roof before giving a quote. Scaffolding and the removal of old mortar may be charged on top.
A tradesman quoted in the ridge tile guide makes the point well. He prices raking out and re-pointing a bungalow ridge at about £180, and lifting, re-bedding and re-pointing it at about £360, and says the second would greatly outlast the first.
Which suits which roof
- Sound ridge, pointing cracked in places. Re-point. It is cheap and buys time, as long as the tiles do not rock.
- Ridge tiles loose. Re-bed with a fixing in each tile, or go dry. Do not pay for pointing over loose tiles.
- Verges crumbling on a concrete tiled roof. Dry verge is usually the lasting answer and suits interlocking tiles well.
- An older roof in plain clay tiles or slate. Mortar often looks more in keeping, and some dry systems do not fit these shapes. Ask what is made for your tile.
- A re-roof. Dry fix throughout is now the normal choice.
One thing dry verge will not do is cure a fault underneath it. If the batten ends have rotted or the edge tiles are broken, they need putting right before the caps go on. A roofer who clips plastic over crumbling mortar without taking it off is hiding the problem, not fixing it.
On Coalville's roofs
Most of the town's tiled houses were finished in mortar when they were built. On the mid-century semis it has often reached the age where the question on this page comes up.
Coalville is not a coastal town and does not get the worst of the weather. It does stand on high ground for Leicestershire, and a gable end facing the prevailing wind takes a beating over the years. If your verge is on that side, dry fix earns its money.
For what the work involves on the day, see ridge and verge repairs in Coalville.
Common questions
Does dry ridge look odd on an old house?
From the pavement, most people cannot tell. The ridge tiles are the same shape. What you might notice is a neat line of small clips between them and no mortar underneath. Dry verge is more visible, because the caps form a stepped plastic edge up the gable. They come in several colours to tone in with the tiles.
Can I have dry ridge fitted and keep mortar verges?
Yes. The two are separate jobs and can be mixed. Many people do the ridge first because loose ridge tiles are the greater risk, and leave sound verges alone.
Why a cracked ridge should not wait
Mortar or dry fix is a real choice, and both are sound when done properly. The poor option is the third one, where cracked bedding stays up for another winter. Loose ridge tiles let water into the highest timber in the house and are the first thing a gale moves.
Say if it is the ridge, the verges or both. Asking is free.